Register   |  Login

Above Average

Wall Street Journal, Wednesday, March 9, 2011, TV Embraces Its Senior Moment.

It seems the median age for American Idol viewers this season was 44 years old. I accept this factoid as true, since anecdotally the only friends I could find, who would recap each week's events with me, were other mom's on Matthew's soccer team and my forty-something year-old friend who lives in Georgia.  

I don't know when or why my younger friends stopped watching American Idol since, ten seasons later, I am still an avid fan.

In fact, maybe it is because of my age that I think American Idol shines.

At forty-five I applaud the contestants' sense of adventure. I have been hard at work since I graduated from college and, in retrospect, a short detour would not have been detrimental to my life or career and, in fact, might have made me more interesting.

I am invigorated by their reckless abandon. Somehow this special lot of young people has drowned out the cynical voices around them and, instead, has chosen the road less traveled.

I am inspired by their leaps of faith. One day they are mixing paint at a paint store or bagging groceries at their local supermarket and sixteen weeks later they are living their dream in front of millions of people. The older you get, the more you believe is at stake and the longer that leap of faith looks. Instead, you learn to be patient and settle for incremental improvements.

I am intrigued by the contestants' physical transformations. Somewhere along the line I made all kinds of decisions about what I could and could not wear. No to hats. No to any clothes that accentuate my tree trunk legs, including - of course - skinny jeans, short skirts, knee high boots, leggings, and a long list of other things. No to most hairstyles. Yes to the "classic" look. And, because I never learned how to apply it, no to eye shadow. On American Idol, stylists give contestants makeovers that are based on who they could be - not that are rooted in contestant's insecurities. It's fun to watch their transformations.

For those reasons and more, the median age of American Idol viewers will continue inching upward with each year older that I get. It's because I will never get tired of watching idealistic people reaching for their dreams.

How about you?  Visit us in the Comment Section and tell us about a show that you think shines and why.

Shining off until tomorrow when I clear yet another article from the shrinking stack that is sitting on my desk. 

Return TopTrackbackPrintPermalink

Comments

Got something to say? Join the discussion »
    Posted @ 6/1/2011 4:34 AM by Brian
    Brian's avatar

    I am not a big fan of Mr. Trump, nor do I watch his show regularly, but I really think Celebrity Apprentice shines. It shines because of the great exposure it gives to charities around the country and the money the contestants raise for different charities.

    Of course, because I grew up with Reading Rainbow and Mister Rogers, I tend to think both of those shows shined BIG TIME for the entertainment and education they provided to me growing up.

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 7:50 AM by chaotickristi
    chaotickristi's avatar

    I don't really watch that much TV still... umm... I have been watching Sanctuary since it came out in 2008 (off and on, there are times I had no TV) because I like the premise: "Stem cells, gene therapy, transplants, cloning; The very meaning of the word "humanity" changes daily in the modern world. But there is a darker side to the evolution of mankind which only a few brave souls are willing to face: There are monsters loose in the world...and they are the key to the future of our race". Each episode shows in some way how something that looks and acts different than expected is just as important to the overall picture as all the 'normies'.

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 8:53 AM by cheryl
    cheryl's avatar

    um.... sorry Claudia, but I hate American Idol. Have never liked that show.

    Cut the cable at my house though we do have Netflix and you can get tv shows on there.

    I used to be a fan of Survivor but I didn't watch this last season and I didn't really miss it that much.

    The boys are watching Myth Busters on Netflix. The guys on there are fun and I like that my boys are learning about science. I can just picture them in 10 years blowing methane into soapy water, watching the column of bubbles build and then setting the thing on fire. Hopefully they won't set anything else ablaze. :)

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 9:10 AM by misty
    misty's avatar

    I think Dancing with the Stars shines. Why, you ask? I enjoy watching those who have zero dance experience grow and change. I love the fact that you can be 30,40,50,60 something and still be accepted as a "dancer". The dancing world is typically a young one. As I get older I have a much greater appreciation for the "older" dancers. I can also relate to the hard work they all put in. The long rehearsals, the weeks away from their families and the fact they are taking on something completely new. If I were a "star" I would love to do this show :). Who knows, maybe I will get my chance in my 50's or 60's.

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 11:23 AM by Peggy
    Peggy's avatar

    What SH!NES I think is the creativity of it all.

    Wow, kudos to Chaotic and Cheryl in regard to your tv situations... I could never 'give it up... because right now I don't have to. One tv pundant... who is on tv mind you... says he never watches cable tv... instead he reads... that's great too. I would love to be so involved in 'stuff' that I didn't have to sit in front of the boob tube.

    Another tv personality listed all the shows she loves to watch... Deadliest Catch, Hoarding Buried Alive, All the Housewive Shows, Kate Plus 8, I Survived, Big Brother, Dancing With the Stars... someone counted her 18 different shows (That's just one season, or half a year)! Do any of those shows SH!NE?

    I've been reading autobiographys of different TV Stars from the 60s & 70s... the last book was by Carol Burnett.... her stories and antics still make me laugh... but she said with today's technology a musical variety show wouldn't make it that far in the ratings because of REALITY TV. I like ME TV and TV Land... I still laugh out loud!

    Andy Warhols 15 minutes of fame? Entertainment at the expense of others dramas? Escapism? Pure utter fun? What I think is great, is that it is employing people...creative people.... cameramen, producers, editors etc....

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 12:15 PM by Claudia
    Claudia's avatar

    Fun responses so far and I agree with Peggy. I love the idea of no tv in your house. American Idol is my guilty pleasure. The only other shows Richard and I really watch are Anderson Cooper 360 and Chopped.

    As I have already mentioned, Chopped shines because of the creativity factor.

    So Cheryl... do tell. Why do you have such an adverse reaction to American Idol? Is it the silly antics at the beginning where they exploit bad singers? I don't love that part, but I still watch from the beginning, so I can follow the stories of the top 12. Inquiring minds want to know... why such strong feelings of hate?

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 1:22 PM by Richard
    Richard's avatar

    I watch because my wife makes me.

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 3:23 PM by Claudia
    Claudia's avatar

    Very funny, honey. You watch it because you love it as much as I do.

    Posted @ 6/1/2011 7:45 PM by karlie
    karlie's avatar

    I love AI, although I don't watch every season. The premise is one that offers hope to those who have a dream and never had the chance or opportunity in that type of venue to really give it a try. It does shine. Some of the whooey they go through is not very shine-y but the process, the development and the creativity mixed in with it all is pretty impressive. I love DWTS - probably the most physically intense of all the shows, next to Survivor - which I watched the first season and that was it. The show I am 'glued' to every Tuesday and I've mentioned here before is NCIS. Who doesn't love Mark Harmon? He shines! We love Myth Busters too! But as a child, I agree with Brian and would have to throw in Romper Room too! Romper bomper stomper boo! Magic mirror etc....

    Posted @ 6/2/2011 1:56 PM by Heather
    Heather's avatar

    Catching up as I was out of pocket all day yesterday first at retreat and then at Lily's birthday party with Jack and Matthew.

    I used to love American Idol but the repetitiveness and predictability got to me after a while and I stopped watching after the season of Kat McPhee.

    I must admit I have an addiction to reality tv though for many of the reasons you mention about AI...I love Survivor and Amazing Race and dream of one day having my family raised enough that I could be gone the requisite 39 days and they wouldn't miss me THAT much. Also Amazing Race...LOVE IT! The challenge, the competition, getting to experience the world! I'd love to race!

    I also watch religiously...So You Think You Can Dance (which has just gotten underway for the summer), Grey's Anatomy, Private Practice, and Sister Wives (curiosity got the best of me on this one).

    Posted @ 6/2/2011 5:20 PM by molly
    molly's avatar

    I often think Heather and I must be the same person or that we were sisters in a former life. ;) I love reality TV as well and also love Survivor and Amazing Race.

    Of the 2, I think the Amazing Race shines. I would love to spend that quality time with my husband, sister, dad, or a best friend and experience the world. Or maybe it will still be on in 20 years and one of my boys would ask me to do it with them. What a great experience.

    Posted @ 6/3/2011 8:39 AM by Heather
    Heather's avatar

    Molly...surely they would give us a sabbatical (paid) to run the race!!! Think of the notoriety it would bring UTA.

    We should TOTALLY apply to run it together. Bal wouldn't do it with me as he hates heights, airplanes and all things dangerous!

leave a reply

 [Quick Submit with Ctrl+Enter]

Remember my details
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail